--- title: $7.25M Verdict Against RJR Upheld by Florida Appeals Court description: A Florida appellate court last week upheld a $7.25 million award for the heart disease jurors found was caused by a decades-long addiction to R.J. Reynolds cigarettes.  image: https://blog.cvn.com/hubfs/GavelAA.jpg --- [![](https://blog.cvn.com/hs-fs/hubfs/cvn-images/cvn-header-logo.png?width=333&name=cvn-header-logo.png "cvn-header-logo.png")](http://cvn.com) ![find_icon](https://blog.cvn.com/hs-fs/hubfs/find_icon.png?width=16&height=16&name=find_icon.png)   - [PRICING](http://cvn.com/pricing) - [CONTACT](http://cvn.com/feedbacks/new) - [LOGIN](https://cvn.com/login)   [![Subscribe-to-CVN-Blog-Graphic-small.png](https://blog.cvn.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Subscribe-to-CVN-Blog-Graphic-small.png?width=860&height=115&name=Subscribe-to-CVN-Blog-Graphic-small.png "Subscribe-to-CVN-Blog-Graphic-small.png")](http://cvn.com/pricing) # [$7.25M Verdict Against RJR Upheld by Florida Appeals Court](https://blog.cvn.com/7.25m-verdict-against-rjr-upheld-by-florida-appeals-court) Posted by [Arlin Crisco](https://blog.cvn.com/author/arlin-crisco) on Jul 24, 2020 11:25:45 AM - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![GavelAA](https://blog.cvn.com/hs-fs/hubfs/GavelAA.jpg?width=770&name=GavelAA.jpg) *Stock image. * --- Miami, FL— A Florida appellate court last week upheld a $7.25 million award for the heart disease jurors found was caused by a decades-long addiction to R.J. Reynolds cigarettes.  In an opinion by Judge Fleur J. Lobree, the three-judge panel of the state’s Third District Court of Appeal upheld the 2018 jury award to Paul Rouse, who was forced to undergo a heart bypass surgery in 1999, when he was 45 years old.  Rouse claims his heart disease was caused by decades of smoking and RJR’s participation in a conspiracy to hide the dangers of cigarettes through much of the 20th century. The case was part of Florida’s so-called Engle progeny litigation, thousands of cases spun from a decertified class action against the nation’s tobacco companies. Engle progeny plaintiffs such as Rouse are entitled to the benefit of the original Engle jury’s findings if they can prove they were individually affected.  RJR argued on appeal that the Rouse trial court erred in denying its motion for a directed verdict on the conspiracy claim. On review, the court noted that because the original Engle jury’s findings that tobacco companies, including RJR, had conspired to hide the dangers of smoking, Rouse was only required to show that he relied to his detriment on statements made in furtherance of the claimed conspiracy and that his reliance caused his heart disease.  But the court reasoned that Rouse was not required to show that he relied on any specific statement related to the conspiracy. “Florida courts have long recognized that to prevail on a conspiracy claim in an Engle-progeny case, a plaintiff does not have to categorically demonstrate reliance on a specific statement from RJR or another co-conspirator made in furtherance of their agreement,” Judge Lobree wrote.  Judge Lobree concluded Rouse presented sufficient evidence to avoid a directed verdict against him. “Not only did Rouse present evidence that he was exposed throughout his life to the tobacco companies’ broad-based misleading advertising campaign, he also testified that his decision to smoke Winston filtered cigarettes was influenced by the way the tobacco companies promoted filtered cigarettes in their advertisements,” she wrote.  “From this evidence, a reasonable jury could have inferred that Rouse might have never started smoking Winston filtered cigarettes or would have quit earlier had he known true facts about filtered cigarettes.” *Email Arlin Crisco at* [acrisco@cvn.com](mailto:acrisco@cvn.com).  Related Information [Read the appellate opinion here.](https://www.3dca.flcourts.org/content/download/640347/7276656/file/2019-629_Disposition_111615_DC05.pdf) [Watch the 2018 trial on demand.  ](https://cvn.com/proceedings/rouse-v-rj-reynolds-trial-2018-11-05) **Not a subscriber?** [Learn how you can access an unrivaled trial video library.](http://www.cvn.com/pricing) Topics: [tobacco](https://blog.cvn.com/topic/tobacco), [Engle Progeny](https://blog.cvn.com/topic/engle-progeny), [Florida](https://blog.cvn.com/topic/florida), [Rouse v. R.J. Reynolds](https://blog.cvn.com/topic/rouse-v-r-j-reynolds) #### RECENT POSTS ### [Watch The Monsanto Roundup Trial On CVN That Teed Up Landmark SCOTUS Herbicide Ruling](https://blog.cvn.com/watch-the-monsanto-roundup-trial-on-cvn-that-teed-up-landmark-scotus-herbicide-ruling) --- ### [Hyatt’s Checkout Policies Blamed At Trial For Diabetic Guest’s Death: Watch Online via CVN](https://blog.cvn.com/hyatts-checkout-policies-blamed-at-trial-for-diabetic-guests-death-watch-online-via-cvn) --- ### [Jury Hands Down $220K Verdict in Tobacco Trial Over Smoker's Death, But Apportions Only 15% Blame to RJR](https://blog.cvn.com/jury-hands-down-220k-verdict-in-tobacco-trial-over-smokers-death-but-apportions-only-15-blame-to-rjr) --- ### [|VIDEO| Shane Read Details Why This Acknowledgment of Loss Was So Critical in a Wrongful Death Case](https://blog.cvn.com/video-shane-read-details-why-this-acknowledgment-of-loss-was-so-critical-in-a-wrongful-death-case) --- ### [It’s Back! Take 40% Off A CVN Subscription With Our Summer Special Discount](https://blog.cvn.com/its-back-take-40-off-a-cvn-subscription-with-our-summer-special-discount) --- ![](https://blog.cvn.com/hubfs/cvn-images/newsletter-heading.png) #### SPOTLIGHT ### [Storytellers: Lloyd Bell and the Power of Performance](https://blog.cvn.com/storytellers-lloyd-bell-exemplifies-the-power-of-performance) --- ### [Who Served Up the Key to an $11M TBI Verdict Against Papa John's?](https://blog.cvn.com/video-who-served-up-the-key-to-an-11m-tbi-trial-win-against-papa-johns) --- ### [The Science Behind Winning Talc Powder Trials](https://blog.cvn.com/courtroom-masters-show-you-three-crucial-tweaks-to-perfect-your-closing-argument) ![](https://blog.cvn.com/hubfs/cvn-images/submit-heading.png) [![](https://blog.cvn.com/hubfs/cvn-images/submitcase.png)](http://cvn.com/suggestions/new) **Our Networks** [Courtroom Connect](http://www.courtroomconnect.com/) [LexisNexis Courtroom Cast](http://courtroomcast.lexisnexis.com/) [Remote Counsel](http://remotecounsel.com/) **Follow Us** - [**](https://www.linkedin.com/company/cvn) - [**](https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZKaUt41jj6nf3YLFfMQHwg) [**](https://www.facebook.com/CourtroomViewNetwork)[**](https://www.instagram.com/courtroomviewnetwork_cvn/)[**](https://twitter.com/courtroomview) **Contact Us** 3901 Roswell Road Suite 302 Marietta, GA 30062 877-838-9067   Copyright 2015 Courtroom Connect. [Privacy Policy](http://cvn.com/privacy) | [Terms and Conditions](http://cvn.com/terms) Courtroom View Network Want to stay updated? Join our newsletter! ```json { "@context" : "http://schema.org", "@type" : "Article", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Arlin Crisco" }, "dateModified" : "July 24, 2020, 3:25:45 PM", "datePublished" : "2020-07-24 15:25:45", "description" : "A Florida appellate court last week upheld a $7.25 million award for the heart disease jurors found was caused by a decades-long addiction to R.J. Reynolds cigarettes. ", "headline" : "$7.25M Verdict Against RJR Upheld by Florida Appeals Court", "image" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://f.hubspotusercontent20.net/hubfs/442422/GavelAA.jpg" }, "mainEntityOfPage" : "https://blog.cvn.com/7.25m-verdict-against-rjr-upheld-by-florida-appeals-court", "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hub/442422/file-1761674370.png" }, "name" : "Courtroom View Network" } } ```