Chancellor William B. Chandler III, predicted last year, in urging the parties to settle their differences, that neither eBay nor Craigslist would be pleased by his ruling in the case, reportedly saying, "I have an uncanny ability to make everyone unhappy."
Nine months after the trial, which was heard December 7-17, 2009, Chancellor Chandler appears to have made good on his promise.
eBay's 28.4% stake in Craigslist, which had been diluted by Craigslist to 24.85%, is returned to its full 28.4%.
However, Craigslist prevailed in its attempt to keep eBay from sitting on its board, which was one of Craigslist's objectives in enacting the invalidated rights plan.
Sign up for CVN's free monthly newsletter highlighting current and upcoming cases and receive a promo code that will give you free access to 80+ highlights clips from the eBay v. Craigslist trial. See the 80+ clips listed here. Get CVN's free monthly newsletter by email, and free eBay/Craigslist clips -- sign up now!
Update: Link to Chancellor Chandler's opinion in eBay v. Craigslist (PDF), and be sure not to overlook footnote 23.